My thought process was that since %100 fan speed (255 on the LED GUI) sits at 24V, so %50 (~128 on the LED GUI) sits at ~12V.
My multimeter confirmed this, but here I sit with a dead fan.
Do you have access to a multimeter? If so, you can test the two contacts on the fan for continuity. Since you can measure the voltage coming out of the board, that would indicate that it’s ok. The fan itself may have been hooked up backwards, and if the fan didn’t have a protection diode built in it may have been damaged.